Clayface early reactions are overwhelmingly positive, with critics who attended DC Studios’ October 13 premiere calling the Matt Hagen body-horror film one of the best of the year. James Watkins directs Tom Rhys Harries in the R-rated adaptation, which hits US theaters October 23, 2026 — a full eight days before the formal review embargo lifts.
DC Studios held Clayface’s world premiere at the Hollywood Legion Theater in Los Angeles on October 13. The studio allowed brief social media reactions from that screening, even though the full critics’ review embargo doesn’t lift until October 21 — two days before the movie opens wide.

What Critics Are Saying
Collider’s Steven Weintraub didn’t hold back on the film’s tone: “It’s a hard R and loaded with brutal scenes that really surprised me.” Other reactions leaned on comparisons to Darkman, The Fly and The Substance to describe the practical and visual effects work, and several singled out the lead performance. “Tom Rhys Harries is a star, literally in the movie and for his performance,” wrote reporter Brandon Davis, while critic Chalice Williams called it “one of the best horrors of the year.”
The consistent note across reactions: almost no comic relief, grim thriller tone from start to finish, and a lead performance built around body horror rather than a sympathetic-villain arc. That’s a deliberate swing for a DC Studios movie — Clayface has usually been a Batman side character, not the center of his own film.
Who Is Clayface, and Why This Version Is Different
The Clayface in this film is Matt Hagen, not the character’s original comics identity. Basil Karlo, the first Clayface, debuted in Detective Comics #40 in 1940 as a deranged actor with no powers beyond makeup and obsession. The shape-shifting, living-clay version — the one this film adapts — is Matt Hagen, who debuted in Detective Comics #298 in December 1961, 65 years before this film. In the movie, Hagen is a rising actor who’s brutally disfigured and volunteers for an experimental medical treatment to restore his face, with horrifying results.
Cast and Crew
Tom Rhys Harries stars as Matt Hagen, with Naomi Ackie as scientist Dr. Caitlyn Corr and Max Minghella as Gotham City detective John Borrelli. James Watkins, who directed last year’s Speak No Evil remake, directs from a screenplay he co-wrote with horror filmmaker Mike Flanagan and Hossein Amini; Flanagan also originated the story. The film runs 108 minutes and carries an R rating on a reported $40 million budget.

When You Can See It Yourself
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| October 13, 2026 | World premiere, Hollywood Legion Theater, Los Angeles |
| October 13-15, 2026 | First social media reactions from critics allowed |
| October 21, 2026 | Full critics’ review embargo lifts |
| October 23, 2026 | Wide theatrical release in the United States |
Early reactions aren’t a Rotten Tomatoes score, but they’re a real signal for how a film like this can perform. R-rated body horror has outperformed its budget before: The Substance turned a $17.5 million budget into $77.3 million worldwide in 2024, a 4.4x return, largely on word of mouth after festival buzz. Clayface’s reported $40 million budget is more than double that, but the premiere reactions give it the same kind of pre-release buzz that carried The Substance into wide audiences once reviews landed.

Frequently Asked Questions
When does Clayface come out?
Clayface opens in US theaters on October 23, 2026. It premiered October 13 at the Hollywood Legion Theater in Los Angeles.
Who plays Clayface in the new DC movie?
Tom Rhys Harries plays Matt Hagen, the actor-turned-shapeshifter who becomes Clayface.
Is Clayface R-rated?
Yes. The film carries an R rating, and early reactions describe it as hard-R body horror with minimal comic relief.
Who directed Clayface?
James Watkins directs, from a screenplay he co-wrote with Mike Flanagan and Hossein Amini. Flanagan also originated the story.
When do Clayface reviews come out?
The full critics’ review embargo lifts October 21, 2026, two days before the wide release.
Internal: see our Clayface final trailer breakdown for a scene-by-scene look at what the marketing has shown so far, and our Mister Miracle casting coverage for more on DC Studios’ 2027 slate. External: The Hollywood Reporter rounded up the first reactions, and Wikipedia has the full cast and production details.











